Best Electric Heating Systems: Costs & Alternatives
The best electric heating system depends on your home and your priorities. A well-designed heat pump generally uses the least electricity for a given heat demand. Infrared heating, electric radiators and electric underfloor heating offer other advantages, including room-by-room control and different installation options. Storage heaters can make use of cheaper electricity at particular times.
To choose between them, compare three things separately: the cost of installation, the energy needed to keep your home comfortable and the price you pay for that energy. A system that is inexpensive to fit is not necessarily the cheapest to run.
This guide compares the main electric heating alternatives for homes in different climates and markets, explains running costs and shows how iHelios PTC film and thermostats work together. It also explains the 39% seasonal efficiency result recorded in the iHelios Ecodesign test report.
Electric heating systems compared
Use this table to build a shortlist. The categories overlap: infrared film can be installed as electric underfloor heating, while water-based underfloor heating can be supplied by a heat pump.
| System | Worth considering when… | Main design or cost consideration |
|---|---|---|
| Air source heat pump | You want to reduce electricity use for whole-home heating. | Space, heat loss, emitter sizing and system design affect suitability and performance. |
| Infrared panels or heating film | You want radiant heating with individual room controls; concealed film can free up wall space. | Direct electric running costs, available installation area and a separate hot-water solution. |
| Electric radiators or panel heaters | You need a straightforward room-by-room replacement. | Electricity tariff and heating hours strongly affect the bill. |
| High heat retention storage heaters | You can store heat using an appropriate off-peak tariff. | Charge settings and heat release need to suit occupancy. |
| Electric underfloor heating | You are replacing a floor and want warmth without wall-mounted heaters. | Floor construction, insulation, covering compatibility and controls. |
| Electric boiler | You want to retain a suitable water-based radiator or underfloor system. | Electrical supply capacity and running costs need careful assessment. |
What is the most efficient electric heating system?
A heat pump generally delivers more heat per unit of electricity than direct resistance heating. It moves heat from another source into the building. Direct electric heaters generate heat using electrical resistance.
At the heating element, resistance heating converts approximately one kilowatt-hour of electricity into one kilowatt-hour of heat. Infrared heating is also resistance heating. The Centre for Sustainable Energy explains electric-heater conversion efficiency. How much of that heat usefully warms the intended room also depends on the installation.
A heat pump with a seasonal performance factor of 3 delivers approximately three units of heat for each unit of electricity across the measured season. This is different from a single laboratory COP figure. Ask for the expected seasonal performance for your home and the assumptions behind it.
Controls still matter. Heating fewer rooms, reducing unnecessary operating hours and avoiding overheating can lower demand. These changes should be included explicitly in any savings comparison, rather than presented as a guaranteed advantage of one heater.
Which electric heating alternative suits your project?
1. Infrared heating: panels, floors and ceilings
Infrared heating provides radiant warmth. With an exposed panel, the heated surface emits heat into the room. With concealed film, the installation warms the floor or ceiling finish, which transfers heat to the room. The room air also warms through heat exchange with those surfaces.
infrared ceiling heating is an option to assess when you want clear walls and plan to retain the existing floor. Ceiling access and the approved construction still need checking. Floor film can suit projects where compatible flooring is being installed.
For a whole-home proposal, request room-by-room heat-loss calculations, a layout and a separate plan for domestic hot water. Energy Saving Trust's infrared heating guidance also recommends a property-specific assessment. Infrared is not automatically cheaper to run than gas or a heat pump.
2. Air source heat pumps: whole-home heating
An air-to-water heat pump supplies radiators or water-based underfloor heating and can heat a domestic hot-water cylinder. It is worth assessing in existing homes as well as new builds.
The design needs to account for heat loss, outdoor-unit location, radiator output and water temperatures. Some homes need emitter or pipework changes; others need fewer alterations. Compare a complete installed proposal, including any applicable funding, with the other options. See Energy Saving Trust's air source heat pump guide.
3. Electric radiators: a straightforward replacement
Electric radiators and panel heaters can provide independent heating without a wet pipe network. Programmers and thermostats help match operation to each room's use.
Changing from one resistance heater to another does not inherently produce more heat from each unit of electricity. Compare temperature control, sizing, installation and comfort rather than relying on labels such as “100% efficient”. For the main categories, see Energy Saving Trust's electric heating guide.
4. Storage heaters: make the tariff part of the design
High heat retention storage heaters store heat during charging periods and release it later. Modern models can include automatic charge control, thermostats and programmers.
Before replacing them with direct electric heating, compare when both systems will buy electricity. A cheaper replacement heater can produce a higher bill if it moves most consumption onto a more expensive rate. Energy Saving Trust explains modern storage-heater controls and how they differ from older models.
5. Electric underfloor heating: plan around the floor
Electric underfloor systems include cables, mats and suitable heating films. They can remove the need for wall-mounted emitters, but the complete floor build-up determines suitability.
Check the proposed flooring and underlay, temperature limits, insulation and areas occupied by fixed furniture. Use the installation instructions for the specific system. Floor materials affect heat transfer and response time; a thin heating element alone does not guarantee fast room warm-up.
6. Electric boilers: keep a wet system
An electric boiler heats water for a compatible central heating system. It can be considered when retaining radiators is important, but it remains resistance heating rather than a heat pump.
Request an electrical-load assessment and an annual cost estimate before choosing it. Include hot-water storage, controls and any required supply or wiring upgrades in the quotation.
Which electric heating system is cheapest to run?
Compare the same annual heat demand at the same electricity price first. Then account for differences in tariffs, control strategies and occupancy.
The basic calculation is: electricity used (kWh) × electricity price (£/kWh) = energy cost (£).
The example below assumes 10,000 kWh of useful space heat per year and a flat electricity price of £0.28/kWh (28p/kWh). These are illustrative inputs, not a current tariff quotation or a prediction for a particular home.
| Assumed performance | Electricity used | Energy cost |
|---|---|---|
| Resistance heating: 1 unit of useful heat per unit of electricity | 10,000 kWh | £2,800 |
| Heat pump: seasonal performance 2.5 | 4,000 kWh | £1,120 |
| Heat pump: seasonal performance 3 | 3,333 kWh | £933 |
| Heat pump: seasonal performance 4 | 2,500 kWh | £700 |
The calculation divides heat demand by the assumed performance factor and multiplies by £0.28. Figures are rounded. It excludes hot water, standing charges, installation, maintenance, finance, solar generation and storage effects. The resistance-heating row assumes all generated heat is useful to the intended space; a real installation may require more input.
For a room-level example, a heater drawing 1 kW continuously for five hours uses 5 kWh, costing £1.40 at the same illustrative rate. Five hours on a timer does not necessarily mean five hours at full power: thermostat cycling and variable input change consumption. Use measured kWh wherever possible.
How iHelios PTC film and thermostats help reduce energy use
iHelios combines temperature-responsive PTC heating film with room-by-room thermostat control. PTC adjusts the film's electrical input as it warms; thermostats control when each room needs heat. Together, they help manage power demand, avoid unnecessary heating and match operation to the way the property is used.
PTC: power responds to the film temperature
PTC means positive temperature coefficient. As the film temperature rises, its electrical resistance increases. At the same supply voltage, current and power input fall. As it cools, power can rise again. This principle is explained in 1-Material's technical guide to PTC film.
For illustration, a change from 1,000 W to 800 W is a 20% reduction in power at that moment. This example explains the calculation; it is not a measured result for every iHelios installation. The actual response depends on film temperature, voltage and the surrounding construction. A seasonal saving must be established from energy use over time at comparable comfort.
Thermostats: heat the right rooms at the right times
Room thermostats interrupt the heating supply when the selected temperature is reached and call for heat again as needed. Programming and independent zones can reduce unnecessary operating hours and overheating compared with poorly controlled heating.
- Room-by-room settings: match each zone to its use, with suitable background temperatures in less-used rooms.
- Weekly schedules: align comfort periods with occupancy.
- Open-window detection: where fitted and enabled, interrupt heating during a detected temperature drop.
- Remote adjustment: where supported, change schedules when plans change instead of leaving heating running unnecessarily.
The available functions depend on the selected thermostat, sensors and configuration. PTC and room controls perform complementary jobs; PTC does not replace the thermostat.
Calculating energy use with PTC and thermostat cycling
For a simplified estimate, use average power while energised × energised time. Suppose average on-state input is 0.8 kW and the thermostat calls for heat for 60% of a five-hour period:
0.8 kW × 5 hours × 0.60 = 2.4 kWh, costing approximately £0.67 at the illustrative £0.28/kWh (28p/kWh) rate used above.
Both the average power and the operating fraction are assumptions, not test results or a forecast for your home. They demonstrate why installed wattage multiplied by the entire scheduled period can overstate consumption. Where the room still requires the same amount of heat, reduced power may require longer operation. Do not subtract separate PTC and thermostat percentages from the equal-heat comparison above: their effects interact. Use metered kWh to assess actual savings.
TÜV Rheinland testing: 39% seasonal space-heating efficiency
The iHelios heating system identified as iH403, iH405 and iH410 was assessed by TÜV Rheinland / CCIC (Ningbo) Co., Ltd. Report GB249125 001, dated 9 August 2024, records a PASS and 39.0% seasonal space-heating energy efficiency (ηs), against the 38% requirement applied under Regulation (EU) 2015/1188, Annexes II.1 and III.
This is an Ecodesign calculation incorporating an electricity conversion factor and control corrections. It is distinct from electricity-to-heat conversion efficiency, heat-pump COP and percentage bill savings. The reported 39% already includes control contributions; an additional thermostat bonus should not be added to it.
The result relates to the tested system and control configuration. Read the full TÜV Rheinland Ecodesign test report and the calculation method used in the assessment.
For an iHelios Gold Premium PTC proposal, combine the relevant product documentation with a room layout, heat-loss assessment and a suitable control specification. Compare underfloor and ceiling infrared heating to choose the construction that suits your project.
Can solar panels and batteries reduce heating costs?
Solar PV can supply electricity to heating when generation and demand coincide. A battery can shift some electricity to a later time, subject to usable capacity, power limits and losses. Neither guarantees that winter heating will be covered by solar generation.
Compare the value of using solar electricity with the export payment you give up. For grid charging, compare the off-peak purchase cost, storage losses and the later import price. Request a seasonal forecast, rather than assuming summer generation represents winter performance. Energy Saving Trust explains solar self-consumption and export.
What should a heating quotation include?
- Room heat loss: the indoor and outdoor design temperatures, insulation, glazing and ventilation assumptions.
- Installation scope: heating equipment, controls, wiring, access work and making good.
- Hot water: the proposed system and its separate energy estimate.
- Running-cost assumptions: annual heat demand, tariff, operating schedule and any predicted seasonal performance.
- Practical requirements: available space, compatible construction, electrical capacity and maintenance.
Use the iHelios heating calculator for an initial estimate. For a project-specific proposal, send your plans to iHelios with room dimensions, insulation details, the intended floor or ceiling finish and your existing heating arrangement.
Adapt the design to your country and climate
Compare systems using local electricity prices, the building’s heat loss and the temperatures expected in your climate. Ask your installer to confirm the electrical supply, approved construction, required controls and applicable local installation requirements. Product availability, installation costs and support may vary by market.
All cost examples in this English edition are in pounds sterling (GBP), using an illustrative electricity tariff of £0.28/kWh (28p/kWh). This is not a current tariff quotation. For your own estimate, use the price on your electricity contract and include time-of-use rates where relevant. The method can be applied in any country using its local currency and tariff.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best electric heating system for your home?
Start by assessing a heat pump if reducing whole-home electricity consumption is the priority. Compare direct electric and storage options where installation constraints, room use or upfront budget are more important. The best choice needs a property-specific design and cost comparison.
What are the alternatives to electric radiators?
Options include infrared panels, concealed floor or ceiling heating film, electric underfloor mats or cables, storage heaters and heat pumps. They differ in installation, heat delivery, control and tariff requirements.
Is infrared heating cheaper to run than a heat pump?
For the same useful heat demand and electricity tariff, a heat pump with seasonal performance above 1 uses less electricity than resistance infrared heating. Installation costs, zoning and actual heat demand still affect the overall ownership cost.
Can ceiling heating replace underfloor heating?
Ceiling heating can be assessed as an alternative when floors need to remain in place. Suitability depends on ceiling access, construction, available heating area and the room's heat loss. A layout should be confirmed before materials are ordered.
Can electric heating replace a gas boiler?
Yes, but a complete replacement must cover both space heating and domestic hot water. Room heaters or heating film do not themselves provide hot water. Include that separate system in the design and cost comparison.
How do PTC heating film and thermostats save energy?
PTC reduces electrical input as the film warms, while the thermostat controls operating time according to room temperature. Zoning and programming can reduce unnecessary heating. Actual savings depend on the previous controls, heat demand and operating conditions; compare metered consumption at similar comfort.
Does 39% seasonal efficiency mean 39% lower heating bills?
No. The 39% figure is the Ecodesign seasonal efficiency result for the tested iHelios configuration. It uses a regulatory calculation and does not represent a measured percentage reduction in household bills.